Mackenzie-Lewis polygraph, London, England, 1919-1926

Made:
1919-1926 in London
maker:
Cambridge and Paul Instrument Company Limited

Buy this image as a print 

License this image for commercial use at Science and Society Picture Library

Science Museum Group Collection
© The Board of Trustees of the Science Museum

Mackenzie-Lewis polygraph, in mahogany case, owned by B.A.Robinson, by the Cambridge and Paul Instrument Co. Ltd., London, 1919-1930

Imagine you're a detective in charge of investigating a truly terrible crime. You're questioning a suspect who denies everything but you urgently need to find the truth. Would a lie detector be the solution? After all, it’s impossible to cheat a lie detector, right?

Lying is often accompanied by small outward signs – avoiding eye contact, or changes in the voice. Physiologists found that lying could cause other physical changes too, such as a faster heartbeat or increased sweating. For proof, they needed to use an instrument that could measure and record these changes.

British heart surgeon Dr James Mackenzie (1853-1925) had developed the ink-writing polygraph in 1906. It recorded the pulse as continuous lines on a long roll of paper, and was used for detecting problems such as an irregular heartbeat. Such polygraphs started being used as lie detectors, but American psychologist and Wonder Woman creator, Dr William Marston (1893-1947), argued that careful interrogation was also needed.

So a ‘lie detector’ doesn't actually detect lies, just physical changes. Whilst it’s not possible to cheat these reactions, it’s not clear-cut proof. Sweating or a racing heart indicates the person is stressed – but is it because they are lying, or because they are innocent and accused of a terrible crime? This is just one reason why evidence from lie detectors is not admissible in court. So it looks like you'd be better off relying on other methods to solve this crime.

Related people

Details

Category:
Clinical Diagnosis
Object Number:
1980-1212
Materials:
base-plate, aluminium and case, mahogany
type:
polygraph
credit:
Robinson, E.

Cite this page

Rights

We encourage the use and reuse of our collection data.


Data in the title, made, maker and details fields are released under Creative Commons Zero


Descriptions and all other text content are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence

Using our data

Download

Download catalogue entry as json

View manifest in IIIF viewer

Add to Animal Crossing Art Generator

Download manifest IIIF

Our records are constantly being enhanced and improved, but please note that we cannot guarantee the accuracy of any information shown on this website.